Singapore
  OR  
CONNECT WITH FACEBOOK
Pocket rocket
Story by C.K Lim, pictures by Azfar Hashim - 11 Aug 2009
Looking for a hot hatch that reacts instantaneously to your every input? Look no further than the Clio R27 and Civic Type R - we see which one is the better pocket rocket

Honda Civic Type-R, Renault Clio R27

The term "hot hatch" - short for hot hatchback - was coined back in the 1970s when car makers fitted uprated engines and sporty suspension to hatchbacks (a popular body style then), instantly transforming these family-oriented models into high performance vehicles.

Thought by many to be the one which started it all, the original Golf GTI was born in 1974 when Volkswagen equipped the standard Golf with a more powerful 1.6-litre fuel-injected engine, and then sharpened the handling. It proved to be a huge success, achieving unprecedented sales.

Not wanting to miss out on the action, other car manufacturers also came onto the scene shortly with their own hot hatch derivatives.

Fast forward to the present day, there are plenty of hot hatches in our market to suit all budgets and preferences. For the enthusiasts on a budget, there is the affordable Suzuki Swift Sport. For the more well-heeled hot hatch lovers, they can choose from the iconic MINI Cooper S, premium BMW 130i or subtle Audi S3.

But if you have about $100,000 to splurge on a hot hatch, there are a handful of models to choose from. Narrow the search down further by insisting on a naturally aspirated engine, and what you're left with are the Honda Civic Type R and the Renault Clio Renault F1 Team R27 (let's just call it the CTR and R27 from now on, lest The Ed accuses me of using it to plump up the word count).

There are several uncanny similarities between them, besides their engines - both are three-door hatchbacks with list prices of around $100,000, they both come with 2.0-litre engines that produce 100bhp per litre and power goes to their front wheels via 6-speed manual gearboxes. How much closer can we get?

The inside story

The interiors of these two hatches could not be any more different. While the Civic's cabin architecture is no less boldly styled than its exterior, the Clio's less extravagant and more down-to-earth.

Bright red "Start Engine" button, innovative two-level instrument layout, loud red carpeting and black-and-red upholstery for the door cards and sport seats - they are all here in the CTR. The driving position is comfortable, albeit a tad tall, and the fabric/Alcantara seats are snug and supportive.

In comparison, the R27's cabin seems cold, sparse and less inviting. You start up the engine using the age-old method of turning the key, and get all information about the car via a conventional instrument cluster. In fact, it looks almost the same as its lesser sibling, with the only exceptions being the high-backed Recaro folding bucket seats (which are slightly too firm) and alloy pedals.

Four full-sized adults fit into the CTR with ease - even a 1.8m-tall person will have no issue with the rear head and knee room. However, in the R27, the rear head room is more generous, but due to its shorter wheelbase, the knee room gets a little lacking for taller occupants.

Both cars have decently large boots for hatchbacks, with 60:40 split-folding rear seats creating much space as and when you need it to.

Index
Road tests you might also be interested in
Rate this article
1 2 3 4 5

Current Rating: 4 of 5
Tell us what you think about this article. Rate this article now.
Have your say
 i will be interested to read who has driven their rides for 10 years.

- ifconfig , Singapore. 16 Aug 2009 12:32PM
 I'll rather read about who is the best workshop in Singapore to tune the best "Hot Hatches". That will be more interesting.
- domino88 , Singapore. 16 Aug 2009 9:32AM
 hmm...that's a good point. will consider that for the next Comparo.
- azfar , Tampines, Singapore. 13 Aug 2009 4:56PM
 JDM CTR is unforgiving compared to British CTR. Jap CTR has almost no sound insulation so it's very noisy, and the suspension is harder. Drive long distance like on NS-Highway will be a torture! British CTR is more comfort oriented, thus it is not as fun to drive as the Jap CTR with more understeer and poorer body control. But as a long distance cruiser, British beats Jap flat. Maybe the editor should have done a comparison between British and Jap instead. Think it would be more interesting since KAH is planning to bring in the Jap version and sell it alongside the British version.
- eugn86 , Singapore. 13 Aug 2009 2:00PM
 oohlins: Sure we all know the JDM CTR is essentially a trackday car in disguise but we're talking hot hatches here in this comparo.
- ck2718 , Singapore. 13 Aug 2009 12:41AM
 the JDM CTR is better choice for a comparison.....
- oohlins , Singapore. 12 Aug 2009 11:57PM
 Hmmm I go for Jap.
- kkchai , Singapore. 12 Aug 2009 6:31PM
 Great choice! R27 is the way to go man!
- eugn86 , Singapore. 12 Aug 2009 9:15AM
Post a response anonymously or
ROAD TEST
Sharp looking SUV with Euro influences.
RESEARCH
The biggest car price hikes and drops!
  • Engine: Straight , 4 Cylinders 16-valve
  • Power: 201 Bhp @ 7800 rpm (100.6 bhp/litre)
  • Torque: 193 Nm @ 5600 rpm
  • Transmission: 6 -speed Manual
  • Kerb Weight: 1345 kg
  • Average User Rating: Not yet available
  • No of Reviews: Not yet available
  • Average User FC: 11 km/litre
  • Latest Price: SGD 86,400
  • Latest OMV: SGD33,905
Buy this car? Get your finances right.
Latest Price (SGD): 86,400 (4 Feb 2010)
Down Payment :
Interest Rate (%)
Loan Period (years):
  • Engine: Straight , 4 Cylinders 16-valve F4R RS
  • Power: 200 Bhp @ 7250 rpm (100.1 bhp/litre)
  • Torque: 215 Nm @ 5550 rpm
  • Transmission: 6 -speed Manual
  • Kerb Weight: 1240 kg
  • Average User Rating: Not yet available
  • No of Reviews: Not yet available
  • Average User FC: 8 km/litre
  • Latest Price: SGD 111,999
  • Latest OMV: SGD30,576
Buy this car? Get your finances right.
Latest Price (SGD): 111,999 (20 Aug 2009)
Down Payment :
Interest Rate (%)
Loan Period (years):
COE Category B
  Category A
Aug 10 Round 2 difference: -524 42,810
Aug 10 Round 1 difference: 445 43,334
Jul 10 Round 2 difference: 6,980 42,889
Jul 10 Round 1 difference: -4,002 35,909
View all COE prices
BUYING GUIDE
Car buyers will find more affordable deals this weekend.