Cousins from the Same Mother

clifford chow
4 Nov 2016
 

Really guys, the cars are so similar, I don’t see the point in comparing…

Recently we took the SEAT Leon 1.2 TSI out for a road test, and we quite liked how the car handled. The design of the Spanish car was refreshing, and rather edgy. We couldn’t help look back at the Volkswagen Golf 1.2 TSI which we also tested some time ago to draw on the parallels that the two cars have.

While Volkswagen does benefit from the brand advantage, we will attempt to dig deep to see which car that little bit better.

We were quite taken aback when we first got our hands on the Leon. The quality of the build, the uncanny resemblance to the offerings of the 1.2 TSI Golf made this car basically Spain’s idea of a Golf. Confused? So were we.

The SEAT’s wing mirrors really stand out and look the part. Following the same edgy creases that line the body, the pyramid-ish mirrors are really a thing to look at. There are refreshing creases wherever you look. The headlamps and tail lamps carry the same edgy design language of sharp crisp lines and acute angles.

The Golf carries a more uniform feel to its design, with termination of most creases with the beginning of another design element. Against the SEAT, design is less fluid, creating strong-looking character. Both cars come equipped with 16” alloys, the Leon comes with what SEAT calls “Design” alloys, while the Golf gets VW’s “Dover” design. Drive comfort from both cars with the 16” alloys are comfortable and the smaller sized rims would also mean tyre changes at a lower cost, just in-case you may be wondering. The flip side to this, is that they do look marshmallow-funny on the cars.

While both cars sit on the same MQB platform, and hence, would logically hold the same wheelbase, the SEAT is just a few mm longer than the VW. I believe that this would be the result of the bumper and body sculpting. Width and height differences are so minimal they are really not worth mentioning.

Dashboard design for the SEAT is neat. Chrome accents line vastly grey and piano black plastic surfaces. Neatly laid out in the middle of the dash, and in-between the air conditioning vents, is a 5” TFT infotainment screen greets you, providing toggles, car information and mobile connectivity. Below that, an SD card slot, and very familiar dual-zone air conditioning unit from the Volkswagen parts bin.

The Golf sports a less upright dash, featuring a very similar air conditioning unit, with dual-zone function. Side-by side middle air vents would mean that the 5” TFT display is sited lower than the one on the Leon.

Behind the wheel in both cars, reveal similar dimensions, how the steering wheel adjusts for reach and rake, even the rake angles are identical. We do however prefer the design of the Leon’s steering wheel, which seems overall better sculpted. Dials for both hatches are also extremely clear and easy to read.

Overall though, there is a bias towards the VW dash, as visually, everything seems more expensive looking and better laid out from a visual standpoint.

To gain access to the boot for both cars, you’d push in on the rear emblem and give it a lift as it pops out to become a handle. You get a very good 380 litres of boot space, dropping the 60/40 folding rear seats down reveals 1,150 litres for the Leon, and a more generous 1,270 litres for the Golf.

Ok now let us dig a little deeper!

Power for both cars from the same mother come from a four-cylinder 1.2 litre turbocharged unit, mated to a 7-speed DSG gearbox. The reason for the 7 ratios in a car with such a small engine is for fuel economy reasons. Meaning, as much as possible, the engines can be kept within the best of their power bands, switching cogs before the engines run out of puff.

The Golf produces 105bhp, while the Leon benefits from a 4bhp more, and 1 more Nm of torque versus the Volkswagen’s already impressive 174Nm.

While there is that added torque and power advantage, the Golf does benefit from a massive 106kg kerb weight difference, topping the scales at 1,229kg.

But good question dear friends, what would that weight advantage give the Golf? Well, century sprint timings tell a different story. The Leon actually beats the Golf’s 10.2s sprint timing by 0.3s. Fuel consumption figures too show a SEAT advantage, with 20.4Km/L of fuel used, versus the German car’s 20.0Km/L.

Maybe that could be the thing that turns the tide in the SEAT’s favour?

But here is where the Golf does shine, the insulation, against outside noises is better, an adjustable boot floor to provide more room, or just for you to easily load and unload items. Boot access from the centre armrest, just in-case you have got yourself a long pointy item in the boot, and you need to haul another three people around. An electrically operated parking brake versus the Leon’s handbrake lever (not that it is a bad thing). And somehow pitting car for car, there is that added feel of luxury that the German car exudes. All this, and also going for about $1,000 less (at $104,400 - 4 November 2016), than its Spanish cousin from the same mother. 


Sell Fast With Ease - SwiftQuote

With SwiftQuote, you get:
  Best value for your car    A peace of mind when selling    Fast sale from start to end

HIGHEST PRICE FOR YOUR CAR

Best offer with no obligations.
Start Now!

I agree to the collection, use and disclosure of my personal data by Carousell and/or such other third party (as may be necessary) and to be contacted (via email, phone call and/or text message) for any purposes in connection with the application of and transaction of the vehicle, in accordance with the Personal Data Protection Act 2012 and Carousell's Privacy Policy.

I swear by that this service is worth your time and effort, compared to other sites, I got the highest offer from SQ and the transaction is very smooth with the dealer. Dealer is sincere and quick too!!

Al Hazmi - 5 hours ago

SwiftQuote helped me get the highest possible price for my car, when many dealers around were low-balling me. Very impressed with their response time and how fast I managed to sell my car. The dealer that bought my car was also very genuine and it was a fuss free process, 10/10 would recommend.

Santhosh Haridass - 5 days ago

Very efficient , i sold my car in 3 days after register with SwiftQuote. would recomend to all buyer to use it.

Lim Leong Boon - 5 days ago

Quick and hassle free. Got a good price for my car

Kok Wen Yen - 2 weeks ago

Fast to get a quote and so easy to complete the transaction with the dealer. Thumb up! Thank u.

Ricky - 2 weeks ago

A happy customer ! Swiftquote provides fast and courteous service. I sold to the 3rd prospective buyer within a week. I appreciate the speed and how swiftquote keeps me updated as things move.

Nitin Pande - 2 weeks ago

Friendly customer service (Ms Renai), fair pricing, easy liaise, easy transaction and easy transfer.

Abdul Rahman Bin Kamis - 2 weeks ago

My experience with SwiftQuote for selling my car was one the best. I got a very good quote, reliable and good purchaser and the was mediated such that gave me peace of mind.

Muhammad Raza Zaidi - 2 weeks ago

Efficient process and platform. Very active and engaging Client Success Manager. Happy and pleasant experience. Thank you.

Ms Yap - 3 weeks ago

Prompt service and experienced agent. Will recommend my friends and relatives .

Suruji Rawi - 3 weeks ago

Engine

Engine Capacity 999cc
Engine Type Inline 3
Compression Ratio 10.5:1
Bore x Stroke (71 x 75.6)mm
Power 115bhp @ 5000rpm
Torque 200Nm @ 2000rpm
Power to Weight 93.9 bhp per ton

Performance

Acceleration 10s (0-100 km/h)
Top Speed 202 km/h
Fuel Consumption (combined) 22.7 km/L

Misc Technical Data

Transmission 7 -speed DSG
Drive Type FF
Steering Electric

Measurements

Body Type 5 Door Hatch
Dimension
(L x W x H)
(4282 x 1816 x 1459) mm
Kerb Weight 1225 kg
Boot Capacity 380 L
Fuel Tank Capacity 50 L

Brakes

Brakes (Front) Ventilated Discs
Brakes (Rear) Discs

Engine

Engine Capacity 1197cc Turbocharged
Engine Type Inline 4
Compression Ratio 10.5:1
Power 105bhp @ 5000rpm
Torque 174Nm @ 1400rpm
Power to Weight 85.4 bhp per ton

Performance

Acceleration 10.2s (0-100 km/h)
Top Speed 192 km/h
Fuel Consumption (combined) 20.0 km/L

Misc Technical Data

Transmission 7 -speed DSG
Drive Type FF
Steering Electric

Measurements

Body Type Sedan
Dimension
(L x W x H)
(4255 x 1799 x 1452) mm
Wheelbase 2637 mm
Turning Circle 10.9 metres
Kerb Weight 1229 kg
Boot Capacity 380 L
Fuel Tank Capacity 50 L

Brakes

Brakes (Front) Ventilated Discs
Brakes (Rear) Ventilated Discs